Skip to content
Medvind Personal

Specialist article

How to get more out of your performance review

Many managers and employees are lukewarm about the annual appraisal. It comes round once a year, often following a reminder from HR, and both parties have a pretty good idea of how it will go. That is a shame, because this conversation can be one of a manager’s most valuable opportunities to support and develop their team members.

Employee in conversation at a meeting table

Published

Why the conversation often disappoints

When the appraisal is seen as an HR requirement, it can easily become a box-ticking exercise. Preparation is minimal, the questions in the template feel unnatural, and the manager works through the form point by point rather than using it as a guide. Another common issue is saving feedback for the annual appraisal. The employee then hears about things that happened months ago and should have been addressed at the time.

The setting also matters more than many people realise. Allow plenty of time, and leave some breathing room afterwards so you don’t have to cut the conversation short in the middle of something important. Put your phone away somewhere else. It may sound obvious, but it says a lot about how much the conversation matters to you.

From annual reviews to ongoing follow-up

One conversation a year is not enough to support an employee properly. Regular one-to-one meetings create a natural space for praise, small adjustments and things that might otherwise go unsaid. How often they should take place depends on the role and the employee’s needs. For some, a short weekly catch-up works well; for others, once a quarter is enough. If you often work from home or across different locations, scheduled catch-ups become even more important, as informal chats in the corridor no longer happen.

One way to structure the year is to start with a conversation about expectations. During this conversation, the employee sets goals in four areas: finance, business, learning and personal development. These are framed as SMART goals, and the employee takes ownership of them. Progress towards the goals is reviewed in two follow-up conversations during the year, which ends with an evaluation.

Even with regular follow-up, the annual review still has a role to play. It provides an opportunity to reflect on the past year, discuss career development and look beyond the next project. Much of today’s development takes place through day-to-day work rather than training courses. This makes it all the more important to pause occasionally and look at the bigger picture.

The notes can be brief. Record what needs to be followed up, who is responsible and when it should happen. Be cautious about recording or transcribing the conversation. When discussing development, trust is essential, and many people speak less freely when they know everything is being recorded.

What HR can do

A good process is developed together with the managers who will use it. This makes it easier for them to take ownership of it and allows it to be adapted to different parts of the organisation. It is also a good idea to start with senior management so they can lead the way. Most importantly, though, managers need training in listening, asking effective coaching questions and giving feedback. A good form is of little use if the conversation itself is not working.

HR-podden episode 267: Get more out of performance reviews, with Ann-Cathrin Eidval

Would you like to hear more about this? Listen to the HR podcast episode about performance reviews here. (opens in a new tab)